Is One Of These Young Actors Sony’s New Spider-Man?

Boy if that’s the shortlist, it’s gotta be Josh Hutcherson. I think he’d be a pretty good Pete.

Of these, I pick Billy Elliot.

This has all the makings of an abortion of a film.
The director has zero experience in actions films and the one hit he does have was so-so.
Taking an 'artistic' director for an action film is very risky – look at the last bond film. The action scenes were confused and totally under-whelming.
Demoncat you're absolutely right – studios are desperately trying to hang onto their Marvel properties to stop auto-reversion back to Marvel/Disney. Witness the attempted re-boots of Fantastic Four & Daredevil at Fox. 2 properties which were very poorly adapted to the screen and totally udner-sold their comic appeal.
I think Marvel/Disney will take the long approach – they have enough on their film-slate for the next 3-5years and won't be in a rush to get the properties back to re-launch them. They will let these other studios flounder and waste their money on unneccessary reboots – don't forget how Warner Bros. killed the first Batman franchise but they had the luxory to wait (they own DC – Batman wasn't going anywhere) and relaunch.

Too old? Two of them are teenagers. Tobey Maguire was, what, 26 or 27 when he made the first Spider-Man.

Dillane kinda of looks like Ultimate Peter Parker.