Marvel Reacts To Runaways Race Bending Accusations

  • 118 Comments
 
Marvel Reacts To <i>Runaways</i> Race Bending Accusations  

When an open casting call for Runaways began circulating earlier this month, many fans were alarmed that the apparent description for Nico Minoru didn’t indicate that the role was for an Asian-American actress. But Marvel isn’t planning to shy away from Nico’s ethnicity, according to the studio.

In a statement released to Racebending.com, Marvel Studios addressed the concerns over the possibility of a non-Asian American actress landing the role of Nico. The statement reads:

“To address your concern over casting for the role of Nico, as we do with all of our films, we intend to stay true to the legacy and story of the comic when casting these parts. Thus, our goal is to cast an Asian American actress as depicted in the comic series and the casting notice will be adjusted accordingly.

As promised, the casting notice has been adjusted since the statement’s release.

This isn’t the first time this year that a popular character’s race has been at the center of controversy in Hollywood. Indeed, Racebending.com was founded in response to the decision to alter characters’ racial backgrounds in M. Night Shyamalan’s The Last Airbender. While it seems that the question of Nico’s ethnicity has been addressed by Marvel, it’s still worth wondering — how upset would you be if a non-Asian American actress won the role of Nico? Generally speaking, does a studio’s decision to alter a character’s ethnic background take you out of the movie experience, or do you look at other factors in determining a film’s overall quality? Let us know what you think in the comments section.

[Link via UGO]

  • Knightoftomorrow

    The more I think about it, the more I wonder if the concept of this series would really work as a movie. I read the original run a few years back, and the one thought that never ran through my mind was “This should really be a movie.”

  • Ben

    Really? I boycotted it because it looked terrible…

  • Alex

    if the girl who plays nico can play nico then i am fine with that XD/ its call acting. we have mexcians play natvie amercians and so on.

  • Azogtheuruk

    As long as Spider-man and Captain America aren't turned black, I'd be fine with any of The Runaways getting a race change

  • jab

    race nerds.

  • BrotherUnitNo_4

    Overacts? Her character was clearly an OTP individual. I mean she tried dying her hair solely because her ex's new squeeze had blue hair at the time. She hooked up with Young Neil just to make Scott jealous. If she didn't overact, the characters actions wouldn't have made much sense.

  • Zombie Uatu

    Race =/= skin colour.

    I find, given the American preoccupation with race, the fact that people miss this basic point quite odd. I'm British-Irish and would actually find it quite offensive for someone to tell me that didn't matter because I have the same skin colour as someone who was just British (or just Irish). Someone posted above that the X-Men are just skinny white people these days, but of those skinny white people I can think of several who should fall into different racial categories entirely.

    I would rather Nico be played by an Asian-American actress, but that said, if they find someone else who can do the part better then they should cast them. Cast the best person for the role, not the other way around.

  • Kiebler

    I wouldn't care since shes a relatively new character from a series that I felt was just horrible.

    But films based on comic properties should respect the fanbase that made them popular in the first place. Especially a fanbase as rabid for detail as comic book nerds.

  • nacarrell

    When Marvel first started making decent movies (I pretend the old punisher and captain america days never happened) I was constantly pissed off because they messed with one thing or another. Why was Jean suddenly a super doctor? Organic webbing? Why was Sue being played by Jessica Alba? Bullseye is now Irish? My favorite fuzzy elf now has like a million tattoos? And Logan grew like 11 inches overnight. Just think of it as “inspired by” and not “based on”. look at it as some sort of What if…? issue. if it is written well, and acted well, I don't have a problem with it. That being said, if there is an japanese actress who looks the part and has some acting chops, give it to her. not because she is asian, but because she can play the part. being asian definitely should sway the bar a bit in her favor, just like being huge and intimidating helped out MCD.

    What I really want to know is where is the outrage over Venom being tiny and Wolverine being 6'2″. Those were the real travesties.

  • Alexa

    One good reason to keep Nico Minoru Asian? Nico Minoru is a JAPANESE NAME.

  • http://twitter.com/aeghast [A]

    “This isn’t the first time this year that a popular character’s race has been at the center of controversy in Hollywood” —didn't know RUNAWAYS were that popular

  • Tesla56

    Really good argument, I just see it a different way
    The only one of those characters whose identity has ever been intrinsically linked to their race is Luke Cage. I want to promote some previous poster's comment that Peter Parker has always been a New Yorker more than a white guy.

  • HiYah

    I don't get what all the fuss is. Nico should be japanese and alex should by african american. It's not even a question. This is who these characters are..you can't simply change someone's race.

    I say that tristan wilds plays alex and ally maki plays nico.

  • reese

    hi ally! you've been pretty active on racebending and here the past couple days trying to advocate yourself for nico huh?

  • Jenncuteness

    Because hell, there are hardly any parts specifically for Asians anyways nowadays, so why obliterate all of the scarce opportunities out there for them?

  • jake hess

    just looked her up. she looks too old to play nico imho.

  • sean r

    I think the casting directors are looking for an attractive girl to play Nico since she is one of the main characters and we all know that a pretty face will boost ticket sales. Ally, quite frankly, is not “uniquely beautiful” enough–she is an average looking Asian.

    Also, she tries too hard to make her eyes look bigger in photos by opening them really wide, which is a disgrace to Asians. The role of Nico Minoru is a ground breaking opportunity and respresents empowerment for Asian-Americans; Ally is not a good fit for Nico.

  • aggiefromno

    Optimally, the group should stay as diversified as they were for the reasons Katie Gill (above) mentioned. Comic book readers have identified with characters based on their experiences and actions, but also their backgrounds and appearance. Movie audiences should have that same opportunity. A larger travesty would be to cast a thin Gert, as that characteristic was more a relevant to the characters. I know that Nico's powers are based in Dark Asian magic, but it never was a plot focal point whereas Karolina's lesbianism was. So, if I had to give up Nico being played by an Asian, I would choose a competent actress because I would rather a solid characterization than a bad one with an Asian face.

    Still not saying that they can't have it both ways because I think they 100% can and should.