Pixar Changes Brave Director, Prompts Sexism Accusations

  • 11 Comments
 
Pixar Changes <i>Brave</i> Director, Prompts Sexism Accusations  

Pixar has caused upset within the animation community by replacing the director of upcoming movie Brave. The problem isn’t that a director was replaced mid-movie, however, but about the replacement of this particular director.

The news that Brenda Chapman will be replaced by Mark Andrews on the project has provoked such upset because Chapman was the first female director not only in Pixar’s history, but the first to have solo-directed an animated movie from a major studio. To make matters worse, Chapman – who wrote and developed Brave – has a strong history within the industry, having been involved in the development of The Little Mermaid, Beauty And The Beast, The Lion King and The Prince of Egypt, to name just a few. The charge against Pixar now is one of sexism, a charge that’s been leveled against the studio for years, due to their male-centric stories and iconography (spacemen, cowboys, cars). It may not be true, but it’s going to take a real effort to convince everyone else of that now.

  • Joe S. Walker

    “a charge that’s been leveled against the studio for years, due to their male-centric stories and iconography (spacemen, cowboys, cars)”

    Sexism? More like PC thought-policing.

  • robvsmith

    This isn't sexism. Male centric topics? Shocking, considering it is a studio founded males, who were the leads in the team for a long time and who made movies based on their childhood interests.

    And you don't get a much more left-leaning group of folks than the Pixar team. San Francisco Bay Area artists making films, come on.

    This is just grandstanding from people who don't want to accept that somewhere in the production pipeline of this movie Brenda Chapman wasn't able to handle all aspects of the job. Even making this a conflict will probably have a worse impact on future roles for minorities because anytime a company gives someone in a “minority” an opportunity and then that person fails, everyone screams sexism or racism.

    And yet when someone who falls into those categories succeeds that same group does not rain accolades on their shoulders. Which I'm also against, because it shouldn't be an issue.

    If someone is good enough they'll get the job done, if they're not they won't. At a company like Pixar, any minority status doesn't impact that and people need to get off their political correctness high horse.

  • Chuck P.

    “but the first to have solo-directed an animated movie from a major studio.”

    Wrong. Jen Yuh-Nelson is currently directing Kung Fu Panda 2 at DreamWorks animation with no co-directors so far.
    She's a woman, and she's Korean. An ethnic minority.
    How's that for being progressive?

  • 123joshlitternambbtw

    Pixar makes boy-centric movies that may have supporting female characters. Spacemen/cowboys/cars/fish are not inherently boy-centric. Pixar's choice to feature male lead characters that have meaningful story arcs may be boy-centric, but is it sexist? Look at the positive supporting roles the women have — Dory (not too bright), Jessie, Boo (who speaks babytalk), Bo-Peep. Compare these to the male supporting characters (Rex, Ham, Crush, Mike, Randall, Doc,Prospector Pete) — sure the male supporting charcters have better lines and more development, but is that sexist? Does the audience of boys really need to know more about BoPeep other than she likes Woody? Do they really need to know about Jessie's loss of her owner? Is playing to your audience sexist?

  • MikeWikowski

    “San Francisco Bay Area artists making films, come on. ” What, that makes them all enlightened thinkers? No, it just means they live in California and are going to develop carpal tunnel before they retire. And saying that males founded studios and thus only want movies that reflect them personally (movies presumably about white, male, liberals who live in CA?) is somehow okay is just dumb. And if everytime someone gives a “minority” an opportunity and that person fails — well if everytime the minority fails, then yes, I'd say there is a systemic problem if only white guys can succeed in a company of white guys.

  • multispaz

    Brother, thank you so much for your bravery. Duplicate you by a thousand times, execute a giant studio recruitment fair and maybe Hollywood will have the ability to really surprise it's audience for a change.

  • multispaz

    Is that sarcasm?

  • http://twitter.com/ThePixarPodcast The Pixar Podcast

    It's true that Pixar has made movies with lots of boy iconography, but girls love them too! And what's more, hadn't the animation industry been controlled by an army of princesses for decades?

  • Mea

    IMO, The Incredibles has the closest thing to a female lead from Pixar thus far – both Elastigirl and Mr Incredible trade off the spotlight through most of the picture. But yeah… as much as I love Pixar's movies, are very much “boys club” possibly as an unconscious response to the whole “Disney Princess” thing.

    I was looking forward to “Brave” to see how Pixar would handle a female lead, and am sorry to hear about the directorial change. :(

  • Anonymous

    I’m not saying they’re enlightened, I’m saying sexism isn’t exactly par for the course for those groups of people, in particular the people at Pixar.

    What is dumb about a male founded studio making movies about things they like? People start companies to make products they are interested in. Lassetter grew up around cars, so he made a movie about cars. That is the culture he grew up with. Why should he ignore that? And why is that a bad thing?

    I never said that every time someone in a minority gets a chance they fail, I said that every time a failure in that situation does occur people get self-righteous about it and blame it on prejudice. In a lot of cases, and odds are this one, it has nothing to do with prejudice.

    Pixar is hardly a group of white guys succeeding with white guys at the expense of all other groups.

  • Marie

    LOL you are kidding me, princesses, yeah… created by guys, right?
    That’s the point, either it’s a male hero oriented story, or a utopic non realistic woman character story (which does not empower young girls out there, believe me), all of those were mainly created by guys, creating a classic stereotypes of what male or female characters are in the western animation world.
    The only guy out there who can create a proper female hero is Miyazaki, and there is a reason why Disney tried to hire him for years…
    I’m disappointed in this, not even about sexism which might or might not be true, there is the fact that it WAS important on many levels as it was… It’s also her project and some people had seen previews of the story and said it was great. I wish we had some more informations on what happened, and I wish that Pixar would actually release a statement about this, because it doesn’t look really good.
    And again, as a female animator in a guys oriented industry, I can’t accept the fact that many guys all over the internet, on many posts about this very topic, felt like they could judge if it was important or not for the man/woman equality in this industry. If you’re a guy, don’t talk about something you will never, ever experience. Let me tell you this, IT MATTERS and yes, this job is really hard sometimes for a woman. It might be changing, and evolving, but it’s far from being there yet, and only a happy few can actually say “gender didn’t make a difference in my work”.