Doctor Who Season 6: 5 Questions About “A Good Man Goes To War”

I think she WAS lying – it would make sense due to the circumstances – but we’ll have to wait to find out.

River didn’t recognise Rory in ‘The Pandorica Opens’ precisely BECAUSE he’s a part of her personal timeline (ie: he’s her father). The Doctor didn’t forget Rory because he hardly knew him at the time he was erased, but for Amy and River, Rory’s a major part of their joined histories. Hence why River, despite being a time traveller, forgot he existed (and also why Amy temporarily forgot the Doctor after he sacrificed himself to reset the universe).

You need to at least go back to the Christopher Eccleston era (Series 1, 2005), and then watch from there up to the present. You’ll miss a few things, references, and great stories otherwise.

Whether you want to watch the classic series is entirely your decision, though.

I kind of agree with your points but i have 2 things to say:
1. About making a new race, if you remember when Donna evoked the tardis and became part doctor part human and the doctor said then that she was amazing due to have intelligence and that human “spice” i think that has some importance of what may come!!
2. i think they are being carried away with the recent storylines, but with the little girl who is the timelord counters jenny the “daughter” of the doctor when he stuck his hand in the DNA multiplyer, i think that they are trying to make the storylines too complicated for people to grasp and then they split the series up which is even worse!!!!

I would like to ask a question on what you guys think is going to happen!!!
Sam

The answer to who they all are and why is everything happening is linkedvto the return of Omega. Rewatch the scene when the Doctor is in disguise as a headless monk. the are nazi style banners up behind thevarmy leadervwith the sign of the omega on them.

A: It is likely River is a sleeper Manchurian candidate and is the one that is supposed to kill the Doctor. It sounds as if she was successful. However it could also be that her parents sacrifice themselves to save the Doctor from River. The good man could be Rory. See B for why she doesn’t mention mom if that is the case.

B: Amy could be a Time Lord. The Master mentioned he was found as a child with his pocket watch. 1: Amy has no parents (but grandparents that don’t talk about their dead kid?). 2: Her house is a 2 story but there was a second flight of stairs. 3: The DNA is “part time lord” conception on a TARDIS doesn’t make someone a Time Lord. That is a pretty awesome mutation if that is the case. If that were the case I would expect Sara Jane Smith to be regenerating after spending several YEARS on a TARDIS. However if Amy were a time lord under suppression this may explain it. (Rani?). Another thing: since when did the lizard chick become an expert in Time Lord physiology able to recognize time lord DNA at a glance on a screen?

C: Stop and think about the first time we meet Song. He dumps her effective in a new Matrix of the whole damn universe’s library. If I were evil that is a pretty good place to be to plot evil stuff. Or in the name of good, she’s in a position to appropriate the library and build a new Time Lord Matrix.

D: The clerics seem to be several steps ahead of the Doctor. Could they have been playing 3 steps ahead? Baiting the Doctor all the way back from the cracks in the wall? Did they face the Valeyard and are trying to cut him off from being created? River is meeting the Doctor in reverse order. At the end of that chain the Doctor could be, through recursion, saving River, himself, who knows but RiverDoctor is an exercise in recursion.

E: Jenny, Doctor Donna, River, even Sexy. The storyline seems to be pointing to a rebuilding of the Time Lords (for better or worse). With all these Hybrids and clones and crap I wouldn’t be surprised if they brought back Tennent via that lopped off hand as the Valeyard….

F: I would wager the reason they think of the Doctor as a warrior is the result of him getting River back as an infant. Since we are dealing with a Time Lord the bulk of the getting her back could have happened in the past. (They could also be attempting to break a pre-destination paradox)

G: The Cuthulu knock-offs have been strangely absent and they have evolved enough to at least project an image through time and space (Time Lord Victorious vision).

H: We still don’t have an explanation on why Amy doesn’t remember the Daleks and Cybermen.

I: In regards to B we do know once you travel in time you are a bit out-of-sync with the continuum so it is likely changes in history may no replicate properly. Since time is always changing it is possible that the Doctor’s death at the hands of the astronaut is a new event that River is unaware of.

J: Post LOST and Battlestar Galactica I have lost a great deal of faith in writers ability to “not make shit up as they go” so do not attribute convoluted plots as “clever” when “made up on the fly BS” would suffice as a description.

K: There are 4 rogue TARDIS units know, The Medding Monk’s, Rani’s, The Master’s, and Sexy. Now we just need 4 Time Lord’s to pilot them: wait… Dr… Jenny…. River… who is the fourth canidate?

A. Possible, especially Rory’s sacrifice.

B. Amy has parents, didn’t you watch last season’s finale? 

C. Doubt it.

D. More than likely that all this started around the time after he regenerated into Eleven. Or even before.

E. I think a return of the Time Lords is more likely than ‘rebuilding’.

F. Could be very true.

G. I don’t know.

H. She didn’t remember them because of the cracks in time.

I. Nice thought, but it’s more likely that River was lying.

J. Watch Fringe. And most of this stuff were planned from last season. And even if it’s made up on the fly, does it really matter as long as it makes sense and is clever?

K. The Master could still return. 

Whilst Eye Patch Lady looks down at me…..How about a regenerated Davros, Female and with legs!!!
Look at the mouth and lips, black and evil and the voice has Davros’s inflection, especially with “Dok-tor”.  Maybe a whim, but, Davros is a fixed point in evolution, not a reused charecter..My timelines are a bit  mixed up…The spacewo/man who kills the Doctor was in current 22 century, but the girl that Amy ‘tries’ to shoot back in 1969, is from the orphanage, now we see her regenerating in the alleyway, so she cant be the same[visually] as the one who kills the Doctor in 2011.  Now if she is Melody Pond, then Young Melody and River are crossing each others timelines.  Amy is held by the Silent, is that  when she is ‘gangered’ and is genetically modified for the birth of Melody Pond.  But when they enter into the monastary Amy and the Doctor say they had been there before without Rory.  Possibly the dead Doctor is a ganger from the Monastary, reduplicated from the information that Flesh Doctor later retains from ganger Doctor’s sonic screwdriver – remember river was saved into the library from her sonic’ in quite a few of these sonic screwdriver that ‘her’ Doctor had made for her.
Lastly, there are a lot of ‘mobiles’ the cot, the orphanage, the pirate ship and somewhere else??????

They wanted Captain Jack but he was busy with Torchwood which is why they couldn’t get him. And Rory’s a human now.