Jonathan Nolan On Controversial Ending of The Dark Knight Rises

  • 55 Comments
 
Jonathan Nolan On Controversial Ending of <i>The Dark Knight Rises</i>  

The ending of The Dark Knight Rises has been debated since the film opened in July, and so far no one has come forward to set the record straight about what it means. Now the film’s co-writer, and Person of Interest showrunner, Jonathan Nolan has offered his take on the somewhat-subjective ending, and he seems to say it’s vague for a reason.

“I’ve long maintained that if you get to that place where people are passionate about it and arguing about what the end of your film means, then that’s great, and who am I to put my opinion in the mix,” he told IGN.

He used his brother Christopher Nolan’s film Memento as an example to explain what he meant. That movie, based on Jonathan Nolan’s short story, has a more intentionally open ending, and it has elicited a similar response from fans.

“This goes back to a conversation that I had with my brother many, many years ago when he first took his film Memento to the Venice Film Festival and we were having dinner afterwards with the cast and crew and realized at that moment, reposed, relaxed, having dinner, everybody sort of letting their hair down a little bit, and we’d had a great response from the audience, someone realized after a few drinks that everyone there — the stars, the producers, my brother, myself — everyone had a different interpretation of what that film meant,” Nolan recalled.

He continued, “Chris and I still disagree about the end of Memento, by the way, so I feel like that’s as it should be.”

IGN also asked about the inclusion of Robin in the storyline, as he was a character that Christopher Nolan had long said he didn’t want to use. Jonathan Nolan explained that having Joseph Gordon-Levitt’s character amed Robin was their way of acknowledging his role in the Batman universe.

“It’s a wink at the audience. There’s such a huge kind of incredible universe that writers from Bob Kane, Bill Finger, Jerry Robinson, onwards, artists and writers who created this massive universe filled with jewels, frankly. So many characters that you can never do all of them justice,” he explained. “But I think we endeavored to do was not the complete story of Batman but our complete story of this character. It’s one of the reasons why I really wanted to see the Catwoman character there, a favorite of mine, and I think the wink towards Robin was an acknowledgement to, you like the character or not like the character, he’s a huge part of that universe for 70 years.”

  • Beast

     Sorry. Don’t buy it it for a damn minute. His death removed any fair critical review of the character. And no, the acting was not amazing. Just because he lost himself into a role and became self destructive is no reason for everyone to ignore everything that wasn’t “amazing” in their eyes.

  • Rickpalmer317

    People are responding to his death and the role both. It is a great Joker that he played; not necessarily the classic Joker, but very much like The Killing Joke Joker. Regardless, who cares whose batman was more like the golden age batman or whose joker was more like the joker Caesar Romero played. Nolan said from the beginning this is his take on Batman, not the comic. He told you going in that it was not going to be entirely faithful to the comics. So it isn’t really fair to judge his work based on that.

  • KIdris90

    Doesn’t matter how much you hated the joker. Fact is that it is great acting. Ledger’s death had nothing to do with praise. Anytime an actor changes his voice and laugh and mannerisms for a role, the critics and industry people go nuts. The same critics who based Lee in The Crow even after he died praised Ledger. If you knew anything about acting, you would understand.

  • KIdris90

    The same people who didn’t care about the deaths of Lee and aaliyah loved Ledger’s performance. You might not have liked the character that the Nolan bros wrote, but Ledger’s acting was amazing. One of the best performances of the lat 30 years. If you knew anything about acting, you would agree. The way he changed every little detail about himself was incredible. Again, you might dislike how the character came across, but the actign itself was amazing. Most people agree, and most people like Nolan’s Batman films. Stop forcing your opinion on others.

  • KIdris90

    So a series that has 2 movies make over a billion dollars and gets wide acclaim from audiences, critics, and people in the film industry is awful to you? Wow. To each his own, I guess.